Well, if there is only one thing a music critic loves to do, it is making a year-end list. Some do ten, some do fifty, some do twenty. Any number is really just as arbitrary as the next one, so I’ve chosen to do fifteen. Of the all the albums I heard this year, these were my favorite, not necessarily the best–though I like to think there is some significant overlap in those two categories. (See also my 2008 lists of Honorable Mentions, Favorite Songs, and Special Releases.)
15. Department of Eagles – In Ear Park

Perhaps one of the more unsettling albums this year, Department of Eagles’ In Ear Park, provided listeners with songs that featured layers of sounds and textures that give it a somewhat creepy vibe. Though it bears much resemblance to DoE’s co-founder Daniel Rossen’s other band, Grizzly Bear, this record was able to step out of GB’s shadow and stand on its own two feet. Department of Eagles seek to combine elements of the 1920s, 30s, and 40s with indie pop tendencies to create a truly unusual record that delights with its straightforward melodies and labyrinthine intricacies. (REVIEW)
14. Randy Newman – Harps and Angels

I’ll admit that I was not a huge Randy Newman fan before this year. In fact, I flat out didn’t like his music. But I listened to this record and just fell in love immediately. Newman doesn’t really try any new tricks here (forcing me to reconsider all of his previous music), he still is crafting witty, thoughtful songs in his classic, piano-driven New Orleans style. Newman delivers his lyrics like an aging prophet, is he singing or is he just talking in a sing-song voice? Is he celebrating life or declaring condemnation on the unrighteous? This album is a rare treat as it is at once among the funniest albums of the year as well among the angriest. On this record, Newman places songs that call for happiness and joy in living next to songs that vent his frustrations with the current political climate in America, he places love songs next to songs that cast a misanthropic eye on his fellow humans–and throughout all of them, his pen combines lyrical wit and effortless melody like few other artists could. (REVIEW)
13. Q-Tip – The Renaissance

Q-Tip’s first record in almost ten years was certainly worth the wait–and it reveals why he is still one of the heavyweights in hip-hop. Tip continues to do what he did in his days in A Tribe Called Quest by creating songs which feature beats that burrow into the skull and words that stimulate the mind. The Renaissance is not so much a rebirth as it is a reminder. Its music is jazzy and smooth putting it in clear contrast to many of the rough, jagged beats of other rappers of the twenty-first century. Q-Tip has made an album without an ounce of fat on it–no gimmicks, no skits, just straightforward songs that grab the listener and refuse to let go. It reminds us that Tip is still one of the most focused and enjoyable rappers making music today.
12. She & Him – Volume One

Actress Zooey Deschanel has found her musical match in singer/songwriter M.Ward. Both Ward and Deschanel have a great appreciation of 50s and 60s pop music which Ward has shown on his own work and Ms. Deschanel displays in this batch of songs she’s written. Ward functions as producer and musician only singing in a couple duets with Deschanel here. But, after all, the focus here is on “She,” not “Him.” Deschanel has made an album that certainly does not sound like most actresses’ debut records. She has a splendidly timeless voice and she is a darn good songwriter. These songs tap into the qualities of the country and pop of yesteryear so smoothly, its hard to believe these songs are a product of the twenty-first century. Yet, they never sound antiquated–truly an amazing feat in this amazing debut.
11. Barry Adamson – Back to the Cat

Barry Adamson has crafted a jazzy rock record that will add a layer of smoke to the cleanest of rooms in which it is played. Back to the Cat is oozing with atmosphere and tension. The album is almost like a book of short stories focusing on various people from the “beaten side of town” with Mr. Adamson as the narrator. Adamson croons like a lounge singer from hell and even the instrumental songs deliver narrative arcs. Its a sticky, humid album which is a rare accomplishment and probably would have ranked higher had I spent more time with it. (REVIEW)
10. Kasey Chambers and Shane Nicholson – Rattlin’ Bones

Who knew that an Austrailian husband and wife could tap into the country-folk tradition so well? Rattlin’ Bones is an album replete with gorgeous vocal harmonies, sweeping guitar and banjo interplays, and electric melodies. The duo share vocal responsibilties, often alternating the melody and harmony parts, but allowing each other to have a little time to call their own here. They explore life and death, faith and family, and love and regret in a set of songs so strong that it would be nearly impossible to spot a weak link. It’s an album with heart and soul and is easily better than all the drivel on pop-country radio today–probably the best country record in the last couple years.
9. Loudon Wainwright III – Recovery

Loudon Wainwright III teams back up with producer Joe Henry as they attempt to excavate an album’s worth of songs from Wainwright’s first four albums from roughly 35 years ago. The music is fleshed out with a full band backing this time around and the words are bursting with new meanings. Many of these songs were already focused on the past and so they are even more potent being sung by 62-year old Wainwright who sounds like he might reach retirement age before he hits the peak of his creative powers. What makes this record so special, so essential, is the wisdom and tenderness with which Wainwright sings the same words he wrote as a cocky twenty-something up-and-comer. In many ways the man who wrote the words is a different person than the one singing them here, making this a wonderfully conversational record. (REVIEW)
8. Stephen Malkmus & the Jicks – Real Emotional Trash

Beginning in his days leading Pavement and throughout his solo career, Stephen Malkmus has always wielded his guitar and his voice in much the same way. Both of them flow along in an almost unpredictable manner which can be initially off-putting. Yet, after a few listens, it all starts to fit together and make sense–as a result, warming up to his records is a very organic experience. Real Emotional Trash finds Malkmus continuing his recent pattern of delving into long jam sessions in the middle of songs, and there are some great ones here. Malkmus’ songs are not as intentionally sloppy as the songs he used to write back in his Pavement days, but they are nearly as funny and charming. Here is an album that never tackles its aim head-on, but approaches it from several angles, leading the listener to the intended conclusion slowly. (REVIEW)
7. Deerhunter – Microcastle/Weird Era Continued


Deerhunter might be one of the most annoying bands around. There is a never-ending hype surrounding the group and a never-ending string of controversies following around front man, Bradford Cox, ranging from his on-stage antics, to his bizzare blog posts, and his uncomfortable, personal, childhood admissions. Yet, cut through all that mess and what you have is a really amazing album that they’ve released this year. The two discs really work well as a single unit but clearly have their own personalities. This proves that Cox and company truly have some pop tendencies and can make music that is less abrasive than their 2007 effort, Cryptograms. Its a sprawling opus in length, and yet maintains a somewhat tight focus providing an enjoyable and unforgettable listen.
6. Bon Iver – For Emma, Forever Ago

Bon Iver, aka Justin Vernon, has created in For Emma, Forever Ago what will probably be the reigning indie break-up album for years to come. Though essentially a folk album, it has enough weird techniques and textures to make it appealing to the indie crowd. Vernon sings with a chilling heartache in his voice and has crafted some tender, beautiful songs that sound as lonely as the Wisconsin wilderness in which they were written and recorded. Its probably Vernon’s unusual vocal style of going in and out of falsetto that initially captures the listener. Its a record with bizarre lyrics that really don’t matter much anyway since the meaning is all in the tone of the voice. (REVIEW)
5. Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds – Dig, Lazarus, Dig!!!

Hot off the success of their primitive, noisy side project, Grinderman, Nick Cave and his Bad Seeds have created an album in Dig!!! Lazarus, Dig!!! that sounds smaller and more stripped down compared to their gospel-saturated, double-disc masterpiece, Abattoir Blues/The Lyre of Orpheus, yet it still packs a punch with its thematic weight and textured sounds. The Grinderman project seems to have done them some good as Cave and Co. are experiencing some fresh creativity in the studio, even combining some of the elemental guitar tones and drones in a song or two here. Nick Cave is still just as obsessed with Christianity and Religion as he’s always been, displayed clearly in the title track which depicts Lazarus, the man raised from the dead by Jesus in the Gospel of John, journeying through twenty-first century America experiencing the good and lots of the bad it has to offer. (REVIEW)
4. The Tallest Man on Earth – Shallow Grave

Kristian Matsson, the Swedish man performing under the moniker The Tallest Man on Earth, has made what is easily the simplest record I heard this year. Yet, it was a record that I returned to often. Matsson’s nasally yelp is delivered with such energy and conviction that, even when his subject matter uses the logic of fairy tales and dreams, its enthralling and engaging. Matsson will immediately draw comparisons to Bob Dylan, and he actually warrants them though that doesn’t appear to be what he’s seeking. Shallow Grave is a simple set of songs that demands countless repeat listens. I, for one, hope that Matsson does not follow in the footsteps of many other here-today-gone-tomorrow artists who received the cursed “new Dylan” label. (REVIEW)
3. Ezra Furman & The Harpoons – Inside the Human Body

Another group following in the tradition of Bob Dylan, is Ezra Furman and the Harpoons. After the high-energy, acoustic songs from 2007’s Banging Down the Doors, Furman and Co. have gone electric, expanding their sound while staying true to their messy, furious style. Furman still hasn’t taken any vocal lessions and the record is better for it. Though the songs on Inside the Human Body might actually be a little weaker than the songs on Banging Down the Doors, it is still a very worthy follow-up and one of the most refreshing, enjoyable records of the year. (REVIEW)
2. Fleet Foxes – Fleet Foxes

Fleet Foxes must be feeling an awful lot like President-elect Obama right now. After all the buzz and the hype, they are atop many year-end lists, so everyone will be watching closely what they do next. Many are expecting them to continue their reign over the indie rock kingdom, while others are waiting to see them fall off the face of the Earth. After these guys released a few tracks on their Myspace in Janurary, their record was one of the most anticipated of the year, and after its release in June, it has been one of the most talked about. Their self-titled debut is a terrific throw back record borrowing stellar melodies and vocal harmonies from The Beach Boys and acoustic rockish-folk from Crosby, Stills, Nash, and Young. As 2008 winds down and a new year begins lots of eyes in the music world will be waiting to see what one of the most talked about bands of the year will deliver next. (REVIEW)
1. TV on the Radio – Dear Science,

Though there have been lots of great records in 2008, none packed a stronger punch or was as much fun to listen to as the messy, apocalyptic dance-rock party on TV on the Radio’s Dear Science,. It is a record that wows on the first spin and just continues to provide new gems with each listen. Including brilliantly composed lyrics, the musical wizardry and producton of David Andrew Sitek, and the soulful crooning of Tunde Adebimpe and Kyp Malone, no album this year achieved greater breadth or depth as what is displayed by these guys from Brooklyn. Much like TVotR’s last effort, 2006’s Return to Cookie Mountain, this record chronicles the frightening paranoia that composes so much of the ethos in post-9/11 America—including distrust of government, fear of death, and the paranoia of being watched. Yet, unlike Cookie Mountain, this record is approachable, accessible, and hopeful as it indicates that a day of peace and redemption is not too far away. All that, plus the fact that each song provides a beat you can dance to, makes Dear Science, the best record of TVotR’s career and my favorite record of 2008. (REVIEW)
Posted by Gavin Breeden 
Posted by Gavin Breeden
Posted by Gavin Breeden 





photo of Baltimore, MD show in September 2008
