
One thing is for sure, the new, happy Springsteen is nowhere near as fun as the angry, fiery Springsteen that has been a prophet of rock’n'roll for more than three decades. The Boss’ ’70s work was a Van Morrison-inspired blend of rock, R&B, and a little funk in which he sang what were basically short stories which idealized and romanticized the colorful tapestry of street life in Asbury Park, New Jersey. Most of the work from this time is superb, particularly The Wild, The Innocent, and the E Street Shuffle and the classic Born to Run. A few years later Springsteen’s music took a darker turn. With Darkness on the Edge of Town, The River, the phenomenal demo cuts that made up Nebraska, and even the synth-heavy, 80s-drenched Born in the USA, Springsteen really played up his blue collar roots and focused on sticking up for the marginalized. In the era of hairbands and other terrible 80s trends, The Boss was the working man’s rock star.
Through all of this he became somewhat of a symbol of the down-trodden in American popular music and this is what Bruce Springsteen is best at. Consider his most recent accolades for The Rising and We Shall Overcome. The former was the definitive, American response to 9/11 and the latter a collection of traditional folk protest songs for the post-9/11 Bush years. His fine 2007 recording, Magic, was his official statement of the 2000s and it was clearly fueled by his anger that his 2004 candidate had lost the race for the White House. Now, he faces an interesting problem: with his man is in the White House, what’s there to be angry about? I’m sure something will come along eventually, but as for now, everything seems hopeful and as a result, The Boss seems to be running dry on anger and inspiration.
As the story goes, once recording for Magic was completed, songs just continued to flow from Springsteen’s pen and he and the faithful E Street Band would record them on breaks from their tour. Though this might sound like a rush of creative energy and an inspired time of writing, it doesn’t show on his new record, Working on a Dream. The songs don’t feel like they flowed from the creative depths of an artist, they feel forced and tossed off. It’s as if Springsteen didn’t give his musical well time to replenish–he just continued to pump it, though nothing was left but muddy water.
For instance, the opener, “Outlaw Pete,” is an eight-minute track chronicling the the times of a baby criminal (?) and it never really takes off. It just moves on and on through moments that are clearly meant to be powerful, but aren’t. I could imagine this song being enjoyable if it built to something, if it had some force or some personality. Contrast this with the aggressive, attention-grabbing opener of Magic, “Radio Nowhere.” On the new record, songs like “Lucky Day,” “Working on a Dream,” “What Love Can Do,” “This Life,” and “Surprise, Surprise” are meant to show a different side of Springsteen as he celebrates love and life, but each of these tracks is bland and passionless. They don’t sound like celebrations, they sound like rehearsals. Working on a Dream also has the dubious distinction of containing some of Springsteen’s worst lyrics: “Well surprise, surprise, come on open your eyes/And let your love shine down.”
In other words, everything pretty much runs off the tracks on Working on a Dream: the songwriting is weak, the performances are uninspired, and the slick, bland production of Brendan O’Brien doesn’t do anything to save it from becoming a complete train wreck. Springsteen goes from self-parody (“Outlaw Pete”) to unbelievable sentimentality (“Queen of the Supermarket”). Even the work of everyone’s favorite rock saxophonist, Clarence Clemons, can’t add much personality to these tunes. At the end of the day, not all of these songs are terrible, but they are not what we usually hear from Springsteen and E Street–it’s Springsteen Lite. It’s not a record that you’ll want to turn off, but it’s just not a record to which you’ll feel a desire to return. After listening to it multiple times, I can’t really recall much from the songs, they all just run together in an stream of music that is utterly unforgettable.
Perhaps, I’m being somewhat harsh on The Boss here, but that’s only because he’s held to a higher standard. He is one of the staples of rock’n'roll. He has a large discography with some staggering high points and only a few missteps. So, we really expect more from him, which makes this record all the more difficult to handle. Though the record is not entirely without it’s bright spots. There is a delightful, blusey number called “Good Eye” and the “bonus track” is the exceptional, Golden Globe-winning song, “The Wrestler,” from the movie of the same name (recently snubbed by not getting an Oscar nomination for Best Song). There is also a touching song called “The Last Carnival” which is dedicated to long-time E Street keyboardist, Danny Federici, who died of cancer last year, though he is featured on some of the songs here. “The Last Carnival” is the last track of the “official album” and there is a brief pause of silence at it’s end, perhaps to indicate the end of the album proper before the bonus track, “The Wrestler,” begins–but I’d rather think it’s a moment of silence for their fallen friend. Sadly, that fifteen seconds of silence might be the most moving moment of the entire record.
Bruce Springsteen
Working On A Dream
Columbia, 2009
Rating: 2.0/5.0